Case: Middle Ground

The N2N-2 clue

The most significant skyscrapers in a Skyscrapers are the 11 and NN skyscrapers, and after those, the N1N-1 skyscrapers. The others are just sort of… ‘uninteresting’, and exist only to fill in the blanks.

That being said, there’s a very unique constraint around the N2N-2 skyscraper!1

Consider the following lane:

36

The N1N-1 skyscraper here is the 44-skyscraper. Think about which cells we could place it in.

It could very well go in the head cell, leaving the 55-skyscraper to go somewhere in the gap:

3455556

And you might think the 44-skyscraper could go in any of the other cells too. Suppose we put it in this one here:

346

Now, by the rules of Skyscrapers we know the 55 can’t go between the 44 and 66:

3456

If this were the case, then we’d see 4 or more skyscrapers, because there’s guaranteed to be at least 1 unobscured skyscraper before the 44.

In this situation, we know the 55 must come before the 44:

35546

This way, it obscures the 44, giving us 2 guaranteed peaks, with the last one coming someplace before the 55. Keep this constraint in mind!

Now… notice we couldn’t place the 55 in the head cell, because this would allow only 2 visible skyscrapers, not 3:

3546

This is pretty obvious, of course, but – combine it with our previous constraint. We said that 55 must come before 44, but 55 can’t go in the 1st cell. So what happens if 44 is in the 2nd cell?

346

There’s nowhere valid to place the 55-skyscraper here! It must come before the 44, but it can’t go in the head cell.

This means 44 cannot go in the 2nd cell, and we can eliminate it from the candidates:

312356

Pretty crazy, huh? Unexpected that the 44 is randomly gone.

So 11, 22, 33 can all go in any cell in the lane, but specifically 44, the N2N-2 skyscraper, cannot go in the 2nd cell.

This deduction works for general NN – but only with a 33-clue, because that’s what facilitates this interaction of constraints.


  1. I know, it sounds outlandish…